A milk tart is a South African staple, a dessert that conjures up images of home, comfort, and loved ones. Long-held secret family recipes and community dessert competitions make up a large part of this tart’s history, and we are so thankful that the wonderful recipes are now being shared with the world.
This tart is not the easiest option for a dessert and takes a little bit of loving labour, but the end result is out of this world. If you’re looking for a quick pudding to whip up, try our peppermint crisp tart. This milk tart recipe, however, is the one that you’ll impress the socks off your neighbours with.
It’s not too sweet, and it’s rich, creamy, and downright delicious. The filling is quite light, because the ratio between the milk and eggs favours the milk. And the browned baked crust is buttery and adds that perfect offset to the creamy filling. Yum!
History of the milk tart
The history of the milk tart is a long one. It originated in the Dutch Cape Colony in the 1700s, amongst the Afrikaner population. It is believed to have developed from the Dutch ‘Mattentaart’, which was a cheesecake-like dessert.
The Afrikaans name for this pudding is ‘melktert’, which translates directly to its English name, milk tart. In the Afrikaans culture – like in Oudtshoorn and the Klein Karoo – this has long been a staple at church bazaars, home industries, and now even supermarkets. You can easily find an instant, hurriedly made version of this tart at supermarkets, and they’re pretty good. But as we well know, it’ll never come close to a homemade milk tart, made with a little love.
This particular recipe was pulled out of a recipe book published in 1984. It was submitted by a woman who was sharing the recipe she inherited from her mother, who got it from her mother. So this one goes way, way back.
What is milk tart?
A milk tart is similar to a vanilla custard pudding. It has a baked crust, and a filling that is very much dairy-based. If you’re looking to make an easy milk tart recipe, you can use puff pastry to make the crust. But it won’t be quite as richly delicious as the made-from-scratch version.
Another important aspect of this dessert’s perfection is the use of real butter. Margarine can be used in a pinch, but it just won’t be as good. Both in the crust and in the filling, butter is of utmost importance for its deep flavour, much like in malva pudding.
What also sets it apart from other vanilla puddings, is the liberal use of cinnamon. Sprinkled over the tarts once the filling has been poured into the crust, this is a very important aspect of the milk tart. If you’re a huge fan of cinnamon, you can cook the milk with a cinnamon stick. But we recommend that you keep things as is so that every flavour shines as it should.
Milk tart recipe
Milk tart crust
- 125 g butter room temperature
- 125 ml sugar
- 1 egg
- 500 ml cake flour
- 10 ml baking powder
- Pinch of salt
Milk tart filling
- 1 l + 125 ml full cream milk
- 25 g 30 ml butter
- 3 eggs
- 200 ml sugar
- 40 ml cake flour
- 40 ml cornflour
- Pinch of salt
- Cinnamon to taste
Instructions for the crust
- Preheat the oven to 200 degrees Celcius and prepare two circular pie dishes with a thin layer of sunflower (or similar) oil.
- Whisk the butter and sugar together. Add one egg to the mixture and mix.
- In a separate bowl, sift the cake flour, baking powder and salt together.
- Add flour mixture to the egg mixture and fold till a dough. You may want to use your hands to ensure that the butter is fully mixed in. The dough might be quite crumbly, but don’t fret.
- Halve the dough between the two dishes, and press firmly. You’ll want to make a little border around the dish so that the filling will not overflow. But be sure to not make any section too thick, particularly in the corners between the base and the sides.
- Place both crusts into the oven, and bake for 10-12 minutes, or until the crust is browning. While the crusts bake, you can get going with the filling.
Instructions for the filling
- In a large pot, heat up the 1 litre of milk and the butter, until boiling point (when little bubbles start to form).
- Separate two of the eggs, and keep the egg whites to the side.
- Whisk the 125 ml milk, the 1 full egg, 2 egg yolks, sugar, cake flour, cornflour and salt together.
- Whisk in a little of the heated milk, so that the eggs do not cook and curdle as soon as they join the rest.
- Slowly add this mixture to the hot milk, whisking all the while, to make sure no clumps form.
- Bring the filling to boiling point again, mixing continuously.
- Next, whip up the remaining egg whites (it will go a lot quicker with an electric whisk) until white peaks form. Fold this softly into the filling.
- Pour the filling into the baked crusts. Add cinnamon to taste, and let the desserts cool and set before enjoying.
Ready to make this traditional milk tart recipe?
This recipe is fun to make, and will certainly get you active in the kitchen. Take it along with you to a dinner party or any other social event, and it’s sure to be a hit. Or just make it for your household, and tuck in with glee.